Edition log · Q4 2026
What changed, and why.
The Q4 2026 readings are the first edition in a quarterly series, graded each edition on the same scale. From the next edition, this page and every card report what changed and why.
- Releasecei-2026-q4 · grading scale v2.1
First reading of the quarterly series across four readings: 50 brands, 41 ports of call, 14 distributors, 27 technology products. The Commercial Excellence Index is on method v2.1; the three companion readings, published 19 September, are on method v1.0. All four read against the same v2.1 grading scale.
- Feb 1–Mar 26, 2026Baseline scoring observations
Baseline scoring observations for the Commercial Excellence Index cover 1 February to 26 March 2026.
- Sep 5–8, 2026Source verification
Source verification dates vary by brand between 5 September and 1 October 2026. Six brands carry bounded pillar-score revisions dated 8 September, identified in the developments on their cards.
- Sep 17, 2026Product & Experience pillar added
Guest-rating evidence counted where a Cruise Critic member rating is on record: 44 of 50 brands. Travel Weekly Readers’ Choice results and newbuild pipelines logged as developments.
- Oct 1, 2026Grading scale v2.1 and a factbase review
Every band minimum moved one point lower, so 17 of the 50 Commercial Excellence Index overall scores read one step higher. Every card was re-checked against current official sources and trade press, and six more pillar scores moved on new evidence within the bounded method. No score was hand-adjusted. Dated 1 October; on the live page from 6 October.
- Oct 6, 2026Display simplified; nothing rescored
The four confidence-component bars (breadth, specificity, recency, primary) were removed from every card, and the Fragility column from the Commercial Excellence Index. No score, grade or rank changed.
- Oct 15, 2026Correction: letters the method does not give
From 19 September to 14 October the Destination, Distribution and Technology cards printed pillar letters on cards the method does not grade (coverage under 60%) and on pillars with no criterion evidenced either way: 216, 72 and 211 letters respectively. Those letters are withdrawn. The same day those three readings moved from the retired v1.3 letter bands to the v2.1 bands already in use for the Commercial Excellence Index. Eleven reading grades changed (ten on Destination, one on Technology, none on Distribution), each named in the correction note on its card. Scores and ranks are unchanged.
- Oct 30, 2026Second evidence pass on the companion readings
We searched again for criteria left without public evidence on 18 of the 23 companion cards that sat between 50% and 59% coverage (the 5 furthest from the gate were not searched; Deployment Durability was not searched). Every new finding was re-opened by an independent verifier first; findings rated thin, or resting on a source already used twice, were not accepted. 38 criteria on 16 cards moved to evidenced, and 12 cards now clear the 60% coverage gate with a provisional grade: 7 Destination (Itinerary Value), 2 Distribution, 3 Technology. No other card changed. The class tables now also print the v2.1 letters for the eleven grades the 15 October correction moved; the readings hub had still shown the v1.3 letters for them.
- Next editionQ1 2027
Each card will carry a “since last edition” block: score movement by pillar, the developments that moved it, and any correction made in light of evidence.
One email, when it publishes
Tell us where to send a note when the Q1 2027 readings publish. One message per release, no drip sequence, and you can stop it with one reply.
Noted. One email, when it publishes.
Book a review · 30 minutes · Both partners
Bring one live decision.
In 30 minutes with both partners, we will stress-test the question and tell you plainly whether deeper work is warranted, including “do not hire us” if that is the right answer.
The leader who owns the decision usually joins: the CEO, CCO, or head of Revenue, Finance or Loyalty. We reply within one business day. What happens next →
Request received.
We reply within one business day, usually with a short note on whether the question is a fit before we book the time.